Liberian politicians’ asset disclosure a farce
--A new study shows
Findings from a study just released show that there is little or no appetite for public disclosure of assets by Liberian political parties and politicians as required by the country’s constitution.
The research study conducted by the Center for Media Studies and Peacebuilding (CEMESP) and published on Thursday said “political parties’ compliance with proactive disclosure of information during 2011 faired lower in comparison to 2005 elections.”
Titled, “FOI in Post Conflict Electoral Environment in Liberia,” the publication further said that in 2011, “no candidate published the required asset disclosure form; and no candidate or party published its financial reports as required in article 83 (d) of the Liberian constitution. On the contrary, it indicated that four out of the five leading political parties had websites where information such as platforms, flyers, slogans and membership updates and press statements were uploaded. “
A similar concern was raised recently by another local NGO, the Liberia Media Center, LMC which said that the Liberia Anti-Corruption Commission (LAAC) ‘’public refusal to release asset declaration documentation from state officials to the public runs contrary to Liberia’s Freedom of Information Act and undermines the principle of maximum disclosure.’’
The LACC had earlier argued that the information under discussion was personal records, and hence it could not be disclosed but LMC disagrees.
Recently, Liberia’s Minister of Information was also quoted as saying that the assets declaration information of government officials was private record.
See details in a CEMESP statement below
“As a UNESCO funded initiative that started with two stakeholders forums, the research and publication component that has climaxed the project must serve as lessons for sister countries in the Mano River basin. During a mini Mano River Union Journalists conference marking the past World Press Freedom Day celebration, Executive Director of CEMESP, Malcolm W. Joseph, dovetailed aspect of his panel presentation on the topic the Importance of Preserving Media Freedom with findings of the said research.
The research spanned across the whole country, entailing expert opinions, focused group discussion, citizens’ survey and literature review-extrapolating access to information laws from around the world; Freedom of Information and Elections in Liberia; and a Glance at the Transitional Literature.
In the SWOT analysis done about the Liberian FOI Law one thing that emerged, as strength is the fact that the Liberian law ranks fifth from global ranking, which gives citizens and non citizens the right to ask for information without disclosing why they need such information.
In terms of weakness, the research noted that Liberian FOI law was passed without an implementing strategy, which in effect creates budgetary unpredictability of a nonexistent strategy; and a truncated appeal mechanism given the slow pace of rolling out the agency. This makes litigation the only recourse, which is very unattractive because of cost and time exigency. Another weakness identified is low policy awareness about the utility value of the law at the level of the citizenry including a weak FOI infrastructure in terms of a functional postal system, internet connectivity beyond the capital city. Regarding the foregoing the publication notes: “ what this means in practice is that request for information from institution such as state owned enterprises, ministries, commissions, etc has to be provided at their head offices, and cannot be done without appearing in person to file the request…”
However, both donor interest and political will- engendered by CSO activism were identified as opportunities; whilst the culture of silence and secrecy constitute the threat to the Liberia FOI law.As lesson for post war MRU countries, it has been recommended that all stakeholders’ media, CSOs, government, National Elections Commission and donors must play their roles well in order for FOI regime to work well. The publication is uploaded on CEMESP website and hard copies are been distributed.” Tweet